|
First Americans
This is not your father's history class!
The theory for the populating of the Americas until the last decade could
be summarized in one quick sentence: During the last ice age Asian hunters
crossed over the Bering Land Bridge and settled the Americas. That theory
is dead! The problem is that it is the only theory put forth by our
textbook, The American Journey from Glencoe, a division of
McGraw-Hill, is the discredited one outlined above.
Mr. Y's Center for the Historically Ignorant has developed a
series of eBooks, CDs that are as easy to use as the internet, that set
the story straight. These eBooks are installed on all the computers in the
classroom.
The first series of lessons grouped
under the heading First Americans deals with the 30,000+ years of American
history prior to the arrival of the Europeans in 1492. This affords the
teacher the opportunity to teach quality lessons centered on the very
diverse people we call Indians. Material has been culled from various
sources that will provide our students the latest and greatest data,
evidentiary material, and exposure to scientific studies that rival that
presented in any university in the nation.
The
First Americans Comparing the discredited Bering Land Bridge Theory
with the Multiple Paths Theory of populating the Americas.
Mapping the Americas In this simple exercise the student will map
major features of the Americas. Geographic literacy is an essential
component of this class.
Cahokia There
was a huge city just east of present-day St. Louis that was the cultural
and trading center of a Mississippian culture that had a larger population
than Paris or London. It was called Cahokia.
PreColumbian
Florida Our state had many thriving cultures and more than a few
stories to tell.
The Maya Everyone knows about the Maya,
those peaceful people of southern Mexico and Central America. Here are a
few things you didn't know...
The Aztecs These are the people Cortes
had to conquer to be able to fill his galleons with gold. They have a
story to tell as well.
Clash of Three Cultures This
video lesson brings all the loose ends together.
Students will understand
the following:
1. The traditional and
modern theories about the origins of the first inhabitants of North
America.
2. The lifestyles and
survival strategies of Native Americans who lived long ago in the
students’ own geographical area.
3. The manner in which
evolving modern theories of human migration are changing the way we look
at history and cultivating awareness of racial and cultural stereotypes.
Materials:
- computer(s) with Internet Explorer (or another browser); word processing software; creativity
software (Microsoft PowerPoint)
- The eBook, First
Americans
- The eBook,
Florida History
- Video: The First
Americans
Procedures:
KWL Chart
Divide a piece of large chart paper into three sections: What I Know; What
I Want to Know; What I’ve Learned. The last column will be filled in
later. Ask students what facts they know about Native American tribes that
lived in their geographic area, and enter their responses in the first
column. As you proceed to the second column, explain to the students that
they are going to perform some detective work by investigating the lives
of the Native American peoples who lived in your area long ago. In
addition, they are going to attempt to discover how those people may have
migrated to your area. The amount of information available to your
students may vary according to the region in which they live, but clues to
the past can be found if they look carefully. Have the students brainstorm
possible resources that might be useful in their search. Keep your KWL
chart posted in the classroom so students can add what they learn from
their research to the third column.
Cooperative
Grouping
Divide the students into groups. Each group will investigate a different
aspect of the tribes that lived nearest to you, including lifestyle,
clothing, food acquisition, social relationships, religious beliefs and
practices, and shelter. At least one group should investigate the
traditional and current theories about the migration of people to North
America. To ensure equal participation by all group members, have each
member pick a job, such as reader, note taker, computer keyboarder,
Internet searcher, or reporter to class.
Research
Using the print, online, and primary resources available, the students
will gather information to share with their classmates about their
particular topic. Make sure students take notes with documentation of each
resource used so that appropriate citations can be made later. If specific
information on tribes in your immediate area is not available, direct
students to the best available sources for tribes in your greater region.
Presentations
Once information is gathered, students can select a project to present
their findings. Here are some suggestions:
- Build housing/village models, dioramas,
or three-dimensional relief maps.
- Write and illustrate informative
posters.
- Create a pamphlet that describes and
illustrates each aspect of the life of Native Americans in your area.
- Mark and label the migratory routes of
Native American tribes and dates for various migration theories on a
large map of North America or create an informative poster or annotated
time line. If there are contradictory theories, students can present
both sides and discuss which seems the most likely. Have students
attempt to determine when the first Native Americans settled in your
area. Was there one group or several waves?
- Create a “museum” of artifacts that
relate to the research. Depending on what students can find, the museum
can be an actual shelf or table set up in the classroom or a virtual
museum composed of relevant visuals found on the Internet and CD-ROMs
combined with student annotation.
To add a technology component to the
student projects, students can undertake one of the following:
- Make an illustrated PowerPoint or
HyperStudio presentation.
- Write and produce a one-act play that
showcases the research findings.
- Write a storybook to teach younger
students about Native American life or migration using creativity
software (KidPix, KidWorks Studio, or Ultimate Writing and Creativity
Center for younger students; ClarisWorks or Microsoft Publisher for
older students).
- Publish a mock historical newspaper that
reports on Native American migration on the North American continent.
(Any of the software mentioned above would be useful for setting up the
newspaper.)
Make sure to provide plenty of time for
students to present their research and projects to the rest of the class.
You may wish to extend their audience by inviting other classes to visit
your classroom or by planning a night for families to visit.
Follow-up
Discussion
The questions that follow will help students understand the issues
underlying their research and examine ways in which American culture’s
assumptions about and stereotypes of Native American life have had an
impact in the past and the present. Students can discuss or debate some of
the conflicting theories about the earliest North American migrations as
well as the political and social issues involving Native Americans.
Subjects such as treaty disputes, discrimination against Native Americans,
insensitive treatment of Native American burial grounds, and the practice
of using tribal names for sports teams can provide stimulating
discussions. If they had the opportunity to rewrite history, how might
your students have treated the Indians differently? Ask them to predict
what the outcome today might have been if we could rewrite history.
Perhaps your students’ newfound understanding from their research and
discussion will help them to have an impact on the future.
As a class, examine
ways in which the American culture's assumptions and stereotypes about
Native American life have impacted the past and the present. List some if
the issues that arise in your discussion, which may include:
- Conflicting theories about the earliest
North American migrations
- Disputes about Native American treaties
- Discrimination against Native Americans
- Insensitive treatment of Native American
burial grounds
- The practice of using tribal names for
sports teams
After your initial discussion, ask students
to choose one issue to research further. Have them write a brief summary
of the issue, considering the impact it has on the Native Americans. How
would they solve the issue?
In Class Discussion:
1. How did the Native
Americans in your area adapt to the local environment? Compare and
contrast their adaptations in the past with the adaptations citizens in
your environment might have to make today. Discuss ways in which each
culture has adapted the most to nature and ways in which each has tried to
make nature adapt to it. Which is the best course? What evidence can you
supply to support your evaluation? On what cultural values are you basing
your assessment?
2. If there were no
electricity or other sources of power, how prepared would you be to
survive? How could you find food? Build shelter? Survive the winter? What
are the five most important resources you would like to have at home if
you were to have an extended power outage? Justify your choices.
3. Why do you think
the practice of naming sports teams after Native American tribes persists
in American society, even though many Native Americans have expressed
their displeasure about it? Why do you think they object to the practice?
Should society change, or should the Native American minority accept the
wishes of the majority?
4. On occasion,
archaeologists have dug up the remains of ancient Native Americans. Should
scientists be allowed to study these remains? Native Americans feel such
remains should be immediately reburied according to Native American
customs. Scientists worry that if reburied, the remains will deteriorate
and lose their value for present and future scientific study. Are there
other options for treatment of these remains? Would it make a difference
to you if these were the remains of your ancestors? Why? Defend your point
of view.
5. Given the treaties
the U.S. government has made with Native Americans, should they as a
people have some rights that are different from those of other Americans?
Defend your point of view with facts.
6. Decide whether
Native American tribes should be compensated for the broken treaties,
damage, and disruption they have suffered since Europeans arrived in
America. Defend why your view is the fair thing to do.
Evaluation:
You can evaluate the
overall project by using a rubric that assesses the quality of work based
on the details of your original assignment. Have students participate in
the creation of the rubric. Discuss the criteria to be used to assess the
process and presentations. What are the minimum standards they should be
expected to accomplish?
Kathy
Schrock’s Guide for Educators offers a comprehensive page of
assessment rubrics for group presentations, cooperative learning processes
and products, time lines, oral presentations, and more.
Extending the Lesson:
Fleshing It Out
Recent archaeological discoveries of ancient human remains in North
America such as the “Kennewick Man” do not seem to be Native American in
origin. These discoveries have reopened the question of how the Americas
were populated, by whom, and when. Significant to these discoveries is the
collaboration between forensic anthropologists, artists, and sculptors,
who together have succeeded in “fleshing out” piles of bones into models
of what such persons may have looked like. (The Discovery Magazine
video The Earliest Immigrants provides a fascinating look at this
collaboration of science and art in the reconstruction of the Kennewick
Man’s skeleton.)
After researching this topic, have your class evaluate the plausibility of
different theories by creating their own models:
- Obtain several identical, inexpensive
sets of plastic human skeleton kits from a hobby store. Divide the class
into groups of four or five and give each group one skeleton. To
accompany each skeleton, write a brief scenario of where the bones might
have been found, and under what conditions. Note any distinguishing
characteristics of the skeleton. For example, “These bones were found
along the coast of the state of Washington. The size of the pelvic bones
indicates the person was a female. There is evidence of numerous broken
bones that did not heal properly, affecting the woman’s posture.”
- Using homemade play dough or purchased
modeling clay, challenge groups of students to literally build their
concept of what that person might have looked like, by adding “flesh” to
its bones. Provide plastic knives or wooden Popsicle sticks as carving
tools to add details.
- Have each group present its model and
explain the environmental factors and other reasons why their “human”
has certain features. Have students hypothesize about other living
conditions this person may have experienced. Ask students to speculate
on why the different groups of “forensic archaeologists” in your class
may have arrived at different concepts and theories.
Native Americans in the Mass Media
For many Americans, attitudes about Native Americans come mainly from
movies and television. Have students conduct research on the present-day
lifestyles and economic and social problems of Native Americans. Ask them
to compare this information with traditional stereotypes portrayed by the
television and film industry. Students can combine their analyses of
movies and television shows into a database, a PowerPoint presentation, a
review for the school newspaper, or a letter to the editor of your local
newspaper.
Standards Addressed:
The
Florida Sunshine State Standards.
This lesson plan may be used to address the
academic standards listed below. These standards are drawn from Content
Knowledge: A Compendium of Standards and Benchmarks for K-12 Education:
2nd Edition provided courtesy of the
Mid-continent Research for Education and
Learning in Aurora, Colorado.
Grade level: 6-8, 9-12
Subject area: World History
Standard:
Understands the biological and cultural processes that shaped the earliest
human communities.
Benchmarks:
Understands how different human communities expressed their beliefs (e.g.,
theories regarding the relationship between linguistic and cultural
development; possible social, cultural, and/or religious meanings inferred
from late-Paleolithic cave paintings found in Spain and France; theories
about the ways in which hunter-gatherers may have communicated, maintained
memory of past events, and expressed religious feelings).
Benchmark: Understands environmental, biological, and cultural
influences on early human communities (e.g., how language helped early
humans hunt and establish roles, rules, and structure within communities;
the proposition that Mesolithic peoples were the first to take advantage
of a changing climate; biological and cultural relationships between
Neanderthal and Homo sapiens).
Grade level: 9-12
Subject area: U.S. History
Standard:
Understands the characteristics of societies in the Americas, western
Europe, and western Africa that increasingly interacted after 1450.
Benchmarks:
Understands the similarities and differences among Native American
societies (e.g., gender roles, patterns of social organization, cultural
traditions, economic organization, and political culture among Hopi, Zuni,
Algonquian, Iroquoian, Mound builder, and Mississippian cultures).
Grade level: 6-8, 9-12
Subject area: U.S. History
Standard:
Understands why the Americas attracted Europeans, why they brought
enslaved Africans to their colonies, and how Europeans struggled for
control of North America and the Caribbean.
Benchmarks:
Understands the cultural and environmental impacts of European settlement
in North America (e.g., friendly and conflictory relations between
English, French, Spanish, and Dutch settlers and Native Americans; how
various Native American societies changed as a result of the expanding
European settlements and how they influenced European societies; the
impact of the fur trade on the environment).
Benchmark: Understands the nature of the interaction between Native
Americans and various settlers (e.g., Native American involvement in the
European wars for control between 1675 and 1763, how Native American
societies responded to European land hunger and expansion).
Grade level: 6-8, 9-12
Subject area: U.S. History
Standard:
Understands federal Indian policy and U.S. foreign policy after the Civil
War.
Benchmarks:
Understands interaction between Native Americans and white society (e.g.,
the attitudes and policies of government officials, the U.S. Army,
missionaries, and settlers toward Native Americans; the provisions and
effects of the Dawes Severalty Act of 1887 on tribal identity,
landownership, and assimilation; the legacy of the 19th-century federal
Indian policy; Native American responses to increased white settlement,
mining activities, and railroad construction).
Benchmark: Understands influences on and perspectives of Native
American life in the late 19th century (e.g., how the admission of new
western states affected relations between the United States and Native
American societies; leadership and values of Native American leaders;
depiction of Native Americans and whites by 19th-century artists).
Grade level: 6-8, 9-12
Subject area: U.S. History
Standard:
Understands the U.S. territorial expansion between 1801 and 1861 and how
it affected relations with external powers and Native Americans.
Benchmarks:
Understands how early state and federal policy influenced various Native
American tribes (e.g., survival strategies of Native Americans,
environmental differences between Native American homelands and
resettlement areas, the Black Hawk War, and removal policies in the Old
Northwest).
Benchmark: Understands the impact of territorial expansion on
Native American tribes (e.g., the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Creek, and
Seminole removals, the significance of the Trail of Tears, the original
lands held by various tribes of the Southeast and those held in the Old
Northwest territory).
Grade level: 9-12
Subject area: U.S. History
Standard:
Understands the struggle for racial and gender equality and for the
extension of civil liberties.
Benchmarks:
Understands how diverse groups united during the civil rights movement
(e.g., the escalation from civil disobedience to more radical protest,
issues that led to the development of the Asian civil rights movement and
the Native American civil rights movement, the issues and goals of the
farm labor movement and La Raza Unida).
|